You might know him as the serious but likable bailiff on the TV show Justice for All with Judge Cristina Perez. However, in 2019, Renard Spivey’s life changed for the worse when he was arrested and accused of killing his wife, Patricia Ann Marshall Spivey. What caused this sad event? What happened during the trial? And what did the jury decide?

In this article, we will explore the shocking case of Renard Spivey, a former TV bailiff who allegedly shot his wife twice in their bedroom closet. We will also look at the evidence, the testimonies, and the controversies that surrounded this high-profile case.

The Case Details

The case of Renard Spivey and Patricia Spivey began on July 28, 2019, when Renard called 911 to report that he had been shot in the leg by his wife during a struggle over a gun.

He also said that his wife was dead in their master bedroom closet. When the police arrived at their home on Briscoe Street in Houston, Texas, they found Patricia’s body with two gunshot wounds, one in the arm and one in the chest. Renard was taken to the hospital for treatment.

The police suspected that Renard’s story was inconsistent with the evidence at the scene and that the shooting was not accidental, but intentional. They also learned that Renard and Patricia had been having marital problems and that Patricia had accused Renard of using steroids or having an affair.

Patricia’s brother told ABC13 that Renard had threatened to kill Patricia before and that he regretted not intervening.

Renard was arrested and charged with murder on August 1, 2019. He was released on a $50,000 bond and placed on administrative leave from his job as a Harris County deputy and a TV bailiff on Justice for All with Judge Cristina Perez.

He pleaded not guilty and maintained that the shooting was accidental and that he loved his wife. His case drew attention online, especially after a viral clip from his TV show showed him being questioned about his marriage by a plaintiff or a defendant.

The Viral Clip of Renard Spivey

While Renard Spivey’s murder trial was ongoing, a clip from his previous work as a TV bailiff went viral on social media. This clip is from a TV show called Justice for All with Judge Cristina Perez. Renard Spivey was the bailiff on the show from 2012 to 2016.

In the clip, a couple was arguing about their marriage in front of the judge, and the judge asked Renard Spivey how long he had been married. Renard Spivey replied that he had been married for over 27 years, and then one of the parties in the case said that he looked “mad”.

Renard Spivey seemed surprised, and the audience laughed. The man then said, “You don’t look happy, brother. You don’t look happy.” The judge intervened and said, “He’s very happy.” The clip then cuts to the news report about Renard Spivey’s arrest for killing his wife.

The clip was widely shared and commented on by many people, who found it ironic and disturbing that Renard Spivey’s marriage was questioned on a TV show, and that he later allegedly shot his wife.

Some people also noted the size difference between Renard Spivey and his wife, and wondered how he could claim self-defense.

Others expressed sympathy for Patricia Spivey and her family, and hoped that justice would be served. The clip also raised questions about the role of reality TV shows in portraying and influencing people’s lives.

The clip of Renard Spivey, a former TV bailiff who allegedly shot his wife, was a striking example of how life can imitate art, and vice versa.

The Trial of Renard Spivey

Renard Spivey was indicted for murder in November 2020, more than a year after the fatal shooting of his wife. He pleaded not guilty and claimed that the shooting was accidental.

His trial began in November 2023, and he was represented by Dick DeGuerin, a famous defense lawyer who had previously won a murder acquittal for Robert Durst in Texas.

The prosecution argued that Renard Spivey had killed his wife intentionally, after she confronted him about his alleged steroid use and affair. They presented evidence that Patricia was shot twice, once in the arm and once in the chest, and that she had bruises on her wrists.

They also played a 911 call that Renard made after the shooting, in which he sounded calm and said that he and his wife had been “arguing and tussling with the gun” in their bedroom closet.

The defense countered that Renard Spivey was a good person with a long record of law enforcement and courtroom service. They suggested that Patricia had shot herself in a suicide attempt, and that Renard had tried to stop her and was wounded in the process.

They also questioned the credibility of the medical examiner and the police investigation, and pointed out that there was no evidence of an affair or steroid use by Renard.

The jury deliberated for about 12 hours before reaching a verdict. On December 6, 2023, they found Renard Spivey not guilty of murder. Renard Spivey and his lawyers expressed relief and gratitude for the outcome, while Patricia’s family and friends expressed disappointment and disbelief.

The case of Renard Spivey, a former TV bailiff who allegedly shot his wife, had come to an end. But the questions and controversies surrounding it remained.

Bottom Line

The case of Renard Spivey, a former TV bailiff who allegedly shot his wife, was a complex and controversial one that captivated the public’s attention. It involved a dramatic twist of fate, a clash of evidence, and a viral clip that contrasted his TV persona with his real-life situation. After a long and tense trial, Renard Spivey was acquitted of murder, but not of suspicion. Whether he was a victim of a tragic accident or a perpetrator of a heinous crime, the truth may never be known.